|
Preface: A Users' Guide |
ix |
|
P.1 A Note to Instructors |
ix |
|
P.2 A Note to Students |
xii |
|
Acknowledgments |
xviii |
|
Glossary of Philosophical Terms |
xix |
|
Part I Writing Philosophy |
1 |
|
1 Writing a Philosophy Paper |
3 |
|
1.1 What is a Philosophy Paper Supposed to Accomplish? |
3 |
|
1.2 Choosing a Topic |
4 |
|
1.3 Moving through Drafts |
11 |
|
1.4 The Only Outline You Need is a Sketch of the Argument You Plan to Make |
12 |
|
1.5 The Cardinal Virtues: Logical Rigor and Clarity of Expression |
13 |
|
1.6 A Checklist for Spotting Problems Early |
14 |
|
2 Philosophical Writing Advances a Thesis with an Argument |
16 |
|
2.1 Consuming Arguments |
16 |
|
1 What is an argument? |
16 |
|
2 How is a philosopher's argument to be recognized? |
21 |
|
3 The principle of charity |
23 |
|
4 How is an argument to be criticized? |
25 |
|
2.2 Producing Arguments |
28 |
|
5 A clearly stated, tightly focused thesis is essential |
28 |
|
6 The introduction states why you wrote the paper and why your audience should read it |
29 |
|
7 The body of your paper follows a strategy to demonstrate your thesis |
30 |
|
8 Consider objections to your view |
32 |
|
9 The conclusion of your paper explains the conclusion of your argument |
34 |
|
10 On words that indicate conclusions and premises |
35 |
|
11 Provide justification for every important claim |
35 |
|
12 What makes an argument philosophically interesting? |
36 |
|
3 The Rudiments of Academic Writing |
40 |
|
3.1 Elements of Style |
40 |
|
13 Use the first-person, active voice |
40 |
|
14 Avoid using a conversational tone |
41 |
|
15 The paper should have a title |
41 |
|
16 Pages should be numbered |
42 |
|
17 The correct use of punctuation |
42 |
|
18 The correct use of Latin abbreviations |
43 |
|
19 The correct use of Latin expressions |
44 |
|
20 The consistent use of pronouns |
47 |
|
21 Grammatical errors |
47 |
|
22 Using a term vs. mentioning it |
48 |
|
23 How to edit or add text within a quotation |
49 |
|
3.2 Elements of Substance |
50 |
|
24 Avoid mere rhetoric: philosophy is not forensics |
50 |
|
25 Avoid using five-star vocabulary words |
52 |
|
26 The standard of precision in written discourse |
53 |
|
27 On expressions such as "It is clear that..." |
53 |
|
28 Use accurate terms having clear referents |
54 |
|
29 Always look for the contrast term |
55 |
|
30 Watch out for mysterious agents |
55 |
|
3.3 Substantive Advice |
55 |
|
31 Never quote the instructor |
55 |
|
32 Never quote the dictionary |
56 |
|
3.4 A Few Frequently Misused Terms |
56 |
|
33 Philosophy vs. view vs. opinion |
56 |
|
34 Concept vs. conception |
57 |
|
35 Think vs. feel |
58 |
|
36 Statement vs. argument |
59 |
|
37 Sound, valid, and true |
59 |
|
4 Explaining Philosophical Texts |
60 |
|
38 Make sense out of the text as a whole |
60 |
|
39 Make sense out of the main arguments in a text |
62 |
|
40 Every quotation requires explanation |
63 |
|
41 Every quotation requires specific attribution |
64 |
|
42 The consistent and meaningful use of technical terminology |
66 |
|
5 The Rudiments of Academic Research |
67 |
|
43 Use the library, not the Web |
67 |
|
44 Primary sources are your primary responsibility |
69 |
|
45 What kind of secondary sources should be used and how? |
70 |
|
Part II Doing Philosophy |
73 |
|
6 Academic Integrity |
75 |
|
6.1 Know Your School's Honor Code and its Policies Regarding Plagiarism |
75 |
|
6.2 What is Plagiarism? |
75 |
|
6.3 How to Avoid Plagiarism |
76 |
|
6.4 Proper Attribution Bolsters One's Scholarly Credibility |
77 |
|
6.5 Cheaters are Likely to be Caught |
77 |
|
7 How to Succeed in a Philosophy Course |
79 |
|
7.1 Practice the Intellectual Virtues |
79 |
|
7.2 Come to Class Prepared |
82 |
|
7.3 Ask Substantive Questions |
83 |
|
7.4 Respect the Arduous Process of Careful Reading and Writing |
83 |
|
7.5 Why is Philosophy So Hard to Do? |
84 |
|
7.6 Why is Philosophy So Hard to Read? |
85 |
|
7.7 On the Critical Nature of Philosophy and a Few Myths it is Useful to Discard |
87 |
|
8 What Does it Mean to Do Philosophy? |
93 |
|
8.1 Philosophers Inquire into Our Concepts and Commitments |
94 |
|
8.2 Philosophy Explicates What is Implicit in Our Concepts and Commitments |
96 |
|
8.3 Philosophical Reflection and the Public Use of Reason |
104 |
|
Appendix I Keywords Cross-Referenced to Section Numbers |
117 |
|
References |
119 |
|
Index |
123 |